China's late-1990s reforms triggered a substantial increase in private sector entry. We explore the origins of this expansion using cross-city variation in pre-reform distress among state-owned and collectively-owned enterprises (SOEs and COEs) within a difference-indifferences framework. We find that private sector entry originated not from the state sector, but from the withdrawal of the once-vast collective sector. SOEs underwent restructuring rather than exiting, consolidating market power and failing to facilitate private entry. Conversely, COE withdrawal released critical market space and resources, spurring broad private expansion. Most entrants were de novo firms, reflecting resource reallocation rather than purely ownership relabeling or privatization. This effect was particularly pronounced in competitive, downstream, and labor-intensive industries. These decentralized COEs, originally embedded in the pre-1978 planned system, preserved latent market capacity that smoothed the transition. Our findings help reconcile the puzzle of how China embraced market forces alongside a strengthening state economy.
展开