详情
Fragmenting the Governance of Telecommunications Sector in China: Implications to China’s WTO Accession and Compliance
The separation of the government from the industry in telecommunications sector was
carried out in a gradualist or experimental manner to make sure a “reform without losers”.
Both the supervising ministries and local governments became the “early winners” who were
in favor of the status quo. A meaningful industrial reform started from 1994 but ended in 1998.
China’s entry into the World Trade Organization (WTO) was just right on time to secure the
outcome of the reforms.
However, determined by the nature of uncompetitiveness and state monopoly, the
telecommunications sector was against the liberalization requested by the GATT/WTO
members. Close administrative and financial connections between the supervising ministry
and subordinate sector caused a high degree of convergence of their interest that in turn
implies that the ministry had strong incentives of protecting the sector. After having terminated
the fragmented governance since 1995, the Ministry of Information Industry (MII) successfully
prevented the sector from giving much concession compared to the other sectors during Sino-
US negotiations. Although a limited concession was made, it is possible that the supervising
ministries would not fulfil its commitment. On the one hand, the MII would refuse to cut off its
administrative and financial ties with the enterprises. On the other hand, the enterprises would
still be willing to be protected by the government for the monopolistic benefits. Even though
the door is half-open to international competition, the Ministry had developed other means to
block the entry of foreign service providers.
A new form of fragmented governance is taking shape since 2003 when the State Asset
Supervision and Administration Commission (SASAC) was founded. It created tensions
between the bureaucracies and might create loopholes for the foreign entry in the future.