详情
The "Clear but Neglected" Premium: Explaining Industry Heterogeneity in Fundamental Return Predictability
Using Chinese A-share stocks from 2007–2021, we study whether and why the return-predictive power of accounting-based fundamental signals varies systematically across industries. We construct a high-dimensional set of 101 financial indicators and estimate industry-specific forecasting models (OLS, Ridge, Lasso, Elastic Net) on within-industry standardized ratios. Predictability is strongly heterogeneous: fundamentals forecast returns reliably in traditional, manufacturing-intensive sectors (Industrials, Utilities, Consumer Discretionary, and Real Estate), but are weak or absent in high-attention “glamour” sectors (Information Technology, Healthcare, Energy, Materials, and Consumer Staples). To explain this pattern, we implement a mediated-moderation framework that links cross-industry differences in the fundamentals–return relation to (i) earnings uncertainty, (ii) investor attention, and (iii) limits to arbitrage. The evidence supports a dual-channel mechanism: fundamental strategies perform best when accounting signals are clear (low earnings uncertainty) yet neglected (limited attention), consistent with stable accounting information being incorporated into prices more slowly in those sectors. By contrast, limits to arbitrage do not explain the industry differences. Overall, our findings suggest that industry heterogeneity in fundamentals-based predictability reflects the interaction between information quality and investor attention rather than primarily trading-friction explanations.